The Kansas City Chiefs brought in another kicker and head coach Andy Reid wound up fielding questions that had nothing to do with splitting the uprights.
Kansas City’s decision to sign Justin Tucker was already drawing criticism Wednesday. Then, Reid was asked what message the move sent to female fans. His brief answer gave critics even more to take issue with.
Andy Reid Points to Justin Tucker’s Completed Suspension
Tucker joined Kansas City’s practice squad after serving a 10-game NFL suspension as a free agent in 2025 for violating the league’s personal conduct policy. Sixteen massage therapists accused him of sexual misconduct. Tucker denied the allegations and was not criminally charged.
Asked about the message to female fans, Reid pointed to the punishment Tucker had already served.
“He’s done his suspension, you know, and took care of that business there. But I’ll leave it at that for you,” Reid said.
Reid also said Kansas City had researched the situation and spoken with people before making its decision, though he declined to detail that process.
PREDICT THE NFL SEASON: PFN’s Free NFL Playoff Predictor
The backlash to Tucker joining the Chiefs comes amid Harrison Butker’s struggles. Butker missed two field goals in Sunday’s 20-3 loss to the Seattle Seahawks and remains on the active roster. Adding Tucker gives Kansas City another option without immediately replacing its longtime kicker.
For those criticizing Reid, the unanswered question was why completing a suspension made the organization comfortable bringing Tucker aboard. His response offered little reassurance to people already unhappy with the signing.
NFL Commentators Take Aim at Reid’s Explanation
NFL analyst Sam Monson acknowledged the difficulty of the question while making it clear that Reid’s response fell well short.
“I understand there’s no great answer to that question, but ‘He’s done his suspension, took care of that business there. I’ll leave it at that’ is a TERRIBLE answer,” Monson wrote.
I understand there’s no great answer to that question, but ‘He’s done his suspension, took care of that business there. I’ll leave it at that’ is a TERRIBLE answer.
— Sam Monson (@SamMonsonNFL) October 28, 2026
Fox Sports NFL columnist Ralph Vacchiano took a sarcastic swipe at the importance Kansas City appeared to place on filling a practice-squad opening.
“It sends a terrible message, of course, but Andy Reid couldn’t care less. I mean, he really needs that second kicker. It’s the last piece to his Super Bowl puzzle. So if he has to sell his soul for that … 🤷🏻♂️” Vacchiano wrote.
BE THE GM OF YOUR FAVORITE TEAM: PFN’s Free NFL Mock Draft Simulator
NFL analyst Brandon Perna questioned the move on football grounds, too.
“Selling your soul for a kicker??? A kicker who was bad the last time he played,” Perna posted.
Selling your soul for a kicker???
A kicker who was bad the last time he played.— ThatsGoodSports (@BrandonPerna) October 28, 2026
Tucker’s final season in Baltimore was his least accurate. He made 22 of 30 field-goal attempts in 2024, a 73.3% conversion rate, and missed two extra points. Moreover, he was the 30th-ranked kicker on PFN’s Kicker Impact Score in that season with a grade of 68.0.

NFL editor Sara Marshall’s criticism focused squarely on Reid.
“All I can say about Andy Reid and his love for excusing disgusting behavior is GROSS,” Marshall wrote.
All I can say about Andy Reid and his love for excusing disgusting behavior is GROSS
— Sara Marshall (@smarshxo) October 28, 2026
Podcaster John Chapman broadened his criticism to the organization and its coverage.
“Insane how much the media has given the Chiefs a pass on bringing in so many players that hurt women and children. Demand more from your organizations, please!” Chapman wrote.
Chapman’s comment reflects broader criticism of the organization, but the allegations involving Tucker remain allegations, not proven criminal conduct. Tucker has denied the accusations, and he was not criminally charged in connection with them.
Denver Broncos reporter Erick Trickel delivered a similarly harsh assessment.
“No team has worse morals than the Chiefs (Browns aren’t far behind). They really don’t care as long as they can win,” Trickel added.
No team has worse morals than the Chiefs (Browns aren’t far behind). They really dont care as long as they can win.
— Erick Trickel (@ErickTrickel) October 28, 2026
Reid wanted to leave the discussion at Tucker’s completed suspension. The response to his explanation made it clear that plenty of people still wanted answers.

